Business and Finance - Asia
Enron's Dabhol Issues Notice To Indian Client on Payments
By DANIEL PEARL
Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
BOMBAY, India -- Enron Corp.'s Indian power
project has given the state of Maharashtra a
notice amounting to a threat to cut off electricity,
raising the stakes in a closely watched dispute
over the bills from India's first big private power
plant.
Enron-controlled Dabhol Power Co. declared a
"political force majeure," saying recent
government actions could harm the company's
ability to "perform obligations." The step is
typically used to dissolve a contract after a war, a
coup or a similar radical event. In this case, the
declaration may be more of a pressure tactic, as
the state government moves to renegotiate a
five-year-old contract for the plant's second
phase, scheduled to start producing power within
a few months.
A spokesman for Dabhol, which
also includes Bechtel Corp. and
General Electric Co. as junior
shareholders, said Monday that
the notice was an effort to
protect the $3 billion project's
lenders, who "have expressed
concern" about the project's
difficulties getting payments. He
declined to elaborate.
The cash-strapped Maharashtra
State Electricity Board, Dabhol's
only customer, has failed to
make payments since December.
A federal government guarantee backs the
payments, but the government has withheld two
months of payments, amounting to $48 million,
citing a claim against the gas-fired plant for
taking two hours longer than promised to restart
after shutdowns. The Dabhol spokesman said the
Indian government agreed Monday to send the
December payment dispute to a mediation panel.
Vinay Bansal, chairman of the state electricity
board, said he disagrees with the force majeure
declaration. Mr. Bansal said Dabhol's notice cites
recent statements by Maharashtra's top official
questioning the need for the project's second
phase, and pronouncements by the federal
government that it wouldn't pay Dabhol until the
shutdown dispute is resolved. The notice, he said,
also cites the state government's creation of a
panel to review, and possibly renegotiate, the
Dabhol contract. The panel is scheduled to release
its conclusions on Dabhol Tuesday.
The notice from Dabhol doesn't spell out what
action the power company might take. Cutting off
power would have limited effect, because the
electricity board has already reduced its
purchases from Dabhol to a bare minimum, letting
the 740-megawatt plant produce at 30% of
capacity. The electricity board blames Dabhol's
high electricity rates, saying it has to buy from
cheaper sources first. Enron says the rates would
be lower if the plant produced at 90% capacity as
envisioned when the contract for the first phase
was reached in 1993.
The Congress Party controlled the state
government in 1993. Another government, led by
the Shiv Sena Party, renegotiated the Dabhol deal
in 1996, and in the process approved the second
phase, which would add an additional 1,444
megawatts of capacity. A new Congress-led
government is leading the effort to renegotiate
the second phase of the deal, under which the
state covers the plant's fixed costs regardless of
how much electricity it buys.
Write to Daniel Pearl at danny.pearl@wsj.com .